Why did the Allies lose Operation Market Garden?

28 September 1944. The OB West report on ‘Market-Garden’ produced in October 1944 gave the decision to spread the airborne landings over more than one day as the main reason for the Allied failure. A Luftwaffe analysis added that the airborne landings were spread too thinly and made too far from the Allied front line.

What did Eisenhower think of Operation Market Garden?

Eisenhower, the supreme commander of the Allied Expeditionary Force. Indeed, Ike approved Market Garden because he believed it held great strategic merit and had the potential to solve several problems the Allies had created for themselves owing to the speed of their advance after the Battle of Normandy.

How many soldiers were killed in Operation Market Garden?

Overall, Market Garden cost the Allies between 15,000 and 17,000 killed, captured, or wounded. The British 1st Airborne Division was the hardest hit, starting the battle with 10,600 men and suffering 1,485 killed and some 6,414 captured.

Why was market garden such a failure?

In the night of 25 September 2.398 British and Polish soldiers withdrew across the river and back into friendly territory. Operation Market Garden had been a highly ambitious operation. In the end it failed due to weather conditions, communication problems and the surprisingly strong German opposition near Arnhem.

Was market garden a success?

Though Operation Market Garden liberated much of the Netherlands from Nazi occupation, established a foothold from which the Allies could make later offensives into Germany and showed the courage and determination of the Allied forces in Arnhem, it remained a costly failure, with lasting consequences.

Why was Dieppe a success?

Dieppe also made clear the difficulties of assaulting a well-defended port, as well as the need for better intelligence on beach conditions and German defences, better communication between infantry on the beach and commanders offshore, and the need for specialized landing craft and tanks able to overcome beach …